About Us

Butler Insurance Agency is located at 620 Lake Land in Mattoon, IL. We have been servicing our community since 1950 and are proud of our long history providing unmatched service to many. Butler Insurance is an independent insurance agency with the ability to help you find complete insurance coverage at the best rate possible. We partner with many insurance providers to assist you with your home insurance, auto insurance, commercial insurance, and many more!

Our agency is committed to excellence. You will find that each of our team members has the knowledge and experience to assist you best while getting to know you personally. We know you will find not just an insurance agent, but a friend.

Meet each of our outstanding team members and contact us today with any additional questions you may have.

Katrina Butler Butler Insurance

Katrina Butler

Carrie Pollom Butler Insurance

Caroline (Carrie) Pollom

Mike Lauter Butler Insurance

Michael (Mike) Lauter

Linda Brandt Butler Insurance

Linda Brandt