Welcome to Butler Insurance Agency

“Serving” your insurance needs

For over 15 years, Butler Insurance Agency has been providing the residents of Longwood, FL and the surrounding areas with exceptional insurance coverage and top of the line customer service. Dedicated to personalized service, they understand that each client is a unique individual with specialized goals and needs. The friendly and knowledgeable staff works one-on-one to build relationships and find all of the best options available. They continually go above and beyond to not only provide insurance policies, but to make sure every client knows exactly what they are paying for and how they are protected.

Whether it be Auto, Home, Business, or Life insurance, it's certain that Butler Insurance Agency is up to date on all of the newest industry knowledge to best serve their clients. That is professionalism you can trust.

Endorsed Local Provider

Our agent, Nicole DeArmas is a Dave Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider, which means not only can she assist you with your Home & Auto insurance needs, but she will do it to the highest standards of the Dave Ramsey philosophy. All ELP's are continuously trained and rated on their service to make sure you get the best in the business to protect you and your family.

Trusted Choice

As a Trusted Choice® agency, we are dedicated to you and are committed to treating you as a person, not a policy. Our Pledge of Performance elaborates what that commitment means and why we feel it is so important to stand by it.


1997 Longwood-Lake Mary Rd
Suite 1001, Longwood FL 32750


(407) 322-8550


(407) 322-8530



View our Carrier List here.